What IFSCA has Looked for
Part 1 of this three-part series explained that the International Financial Services Centres Authority’s (“IFSCA”) 26 enforcement actions are the product of an 18-month supervisory program that was converted into formal proceedings in a single sweep. Part 2 examines the substance of the orders: (i) the seven issues that recur; (ii) the escalation sequence IFSCA has followed before issuing a notice; and (iii) the defenses that have and have not succeeded.
Seven Issues, One Theme
Each enforcement action of IFSCA has been classified below by reference to the issues the order actually decides; a single action may involve more than one issue. In 13 of the 26 actions, the issue concerns whether the entity had a physical presence in Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (“GIFT City”), namely, whether the office was open, whether the key managerial personnel were present and whether the business was conducted from the International Financial Services Centre (“IFSC”) rather than elsewhere. Taken together with the reporting, fee and non-commencement cases, approximately four in five actions concern whether a registration corresponded to a functioning and compliant business. The remaining actions, a growing minority, concern what an operating business did with its clients and how it dealt with the perimeter of the relevant registration.

Issue 1: Substance and physical presence
Regulation 7 of the IFSCA (Fund Management) Regulations, 2025 requires a fund management entity to designate a principal officer and, in the case of a registered entity, a compliance officer, each based in the IFSC; Regulation 10(1) requires “the necessary infrastructure like adequate office space, equipment, communication facilities and manpower to effectively discharge its activities,” commensurate with the size of the entity’s operations, in an office that is “dedicated, secured and accessible only by authorised person(s).” Further, Regulation 9(1) of the IFSCA (Capital Market Intermediaries) Regulations, 2025 provides: “A capital market intermediary shall designate a principal officer and a separate compliance officer based out of IFSC.”
The legislative intent behind these provisions is clear: GIFT City is intended to be a jurisdiction of substance, and that purpose is defeated where a registration is held by an entity whose people and decisions sit elsewhere. IFSCA has tested compliance with these requirements through unannounced visits. The fund management orders record eight visits on identical dates between July 31, 2024 and May 14, 2025, which indicates that the visits formed part of a program across the fund management population rather than a response to any single entity. The findings from these visits were significant. Mplier Venture Partners’ office was closed on all eight occasions; Terazo Fintech’s office was closed on six, and on the two occasions it was open, none of its key managerial personnel were present; Neo Asset Management’s principal officer was absent on four consecutive visits despite an advisory issued in the interim; and the office of String AI, a broker-dealer, was closed on both visits, String AI employed three people in total, and all of String AI’s trade orders had been placed from IP addresses outside GIFT City.
The orders also indicate what will, and will not, suffice as an answer to the charge. Jashvik Capital Management offers a useful contrast. Jashvik’s office was closed on two visits and the entity’s personnel were absent on two others, yet the Quasi-Judicial Adjudicating Authority (“QJAE”) held that the charge under Regulation 7 “is not established”: Jashvik had in fact appointed the required personnel, the quarterly reports of Jashvik recorded those appointments, Jashvik produced a lease deed and equipment records and the explanations offered for the later absences were accepted. The only failure related to an advisory that Jashvik had neither acknowledged nor responded to, for which Jashvik received directions but no penalty. Terazo, on the other hand, had documented and communicated each absence of the compliance officer and was nonetheless penalized because, in the QJAE’s words, Terazo had “failed to provide any explanation regarding the absence of the Principal Officer during the eight visits.” The QJAE appears to be drawing a distinction between an IFSC-based team that was occasionally elsewhere and a team that was never there at all. Entities have offered floods, rainfall, staffing crises and the novelty of the regime in mitigation; each was considered, and none was accepted as an answer to the charge.
Issue 2: Reporting
Nine actions concern periodic reports that were not filed, were filed late or were inaccurate. The broker-dealer cases were triggered by IFSCA’s circular of February 8, 2024, which required every capital market intermediary to file a quarterly report within 15 days of quarter-end. Three long-inactive brokers (Silver Stream Equities, Dynamic Equities and Karvy Broking) did not file at all, and a fourth (Gateway Financial Services) filed four quarters late. Silver Stream and Dynamic contended, in substance, that an inactive entity has nothing to report. The contention did not succeed: the QJAE held that inactivity and financial stress do not suspend a reporting obligation, and that the exchange communications on which Silver Stream relied had been sent in 2021 in connection with a surrender application that IFSCA had never processed, such that the obligation had continued throughout.
The fund management cases, by contrast, concern the accuracy of reports rather than whether reports were filed. Abans left Table 3.3 of the quarterly report (a look-through of debt securities) blank in every report filed, and the QJAE declined to treat the repeated omission as inadvertent. We Founder Circle submitted five consecutive periodic reports that misstated the entity’s headcount, legal form and net worth, and these misstatements were treated as a separate violation. Rising Omega’s inaccurate quarterly reports were characterized as “a serious lapse in reporting obligations,” despite Rising Omega’s submission that the errors arose from classification difficulties in the early months of operation. These orders indicate that IFSCA treats an unreliable report as no better than a report that was not filed. The quarterly report has become IFSCA’s principal supervisory tool and, where inaccurate, an independent ground of liability.
Issue 3: Non-commencement and dormant registrations
Six actions concern entities that obtained a registration but never used the registration, and the orders in these cases follow a distinct line of reasoning. In LMB Insurance Brokers, the QJAE held that “opening of office is a condition precedent for granting registration and accordingly that cannot be taken as commencement of business;” commencement means undertaking the licensed activity, and an intermediary that had not procured a single policy within the 180 days permitted by Regulation 12(4) of the IFSCA (Insurance Intermediary) Regulations, 2021 had therefore not commenced business. Majortrend Capital, a broker that had never onboarded a client and had reported nil net worth in three successive quarterly reports, was directed not to commence or conduct any business until the broker restored the required net worth and office. The registration of Darwin Platform Aircraft Leasing was canceled because Darwin never filed the auditor’s certificate confirming the USD 200 thousand capital infusion and never intimated commencement of business.
Dormant registrants should take note of the corollary: an unprocessed surrender application does not amount to an exit. Silver Stream applied to surrender its registration in 2021 and remained liable for every quarterly report until 2026; Majortrend had been “pursuing regulatory exit since 2018” and the registration of Karvy Broking, whose terminals had been deactivated in December 2019, was canceled ex parte in May 2026, after the notice to Karvy had to be served by affixture at the entity’s last known address. In effect, an unused registration is not a dormant asset but a continuing liability, and the only way to bring that liability to an end is to complete the surrender.
Issue 4: Fees
Six actions involve unpaid annual or recurring fees under IFSCA’s fee circular of May 17, 2023 (as amended), and late fees have been the preferred sanction for reporting defaults. Two points are worth noting. First, Kredx Ventures repeatedly sought a waiver of the annual fee on the basis that the Kredx trade-finance platform was pre-revenue; each request was refused, and the QJAE held that a further request, which remained unanswered, could not excuse non-payment of a fee that had already been demanded. Second, LMB initially challenged IFSCA’s legal authority to levy a recurring fee, but later withdrew the challenge and offered to pay; the QJAE recorded the withdrawal but canceled the registration nonetheless, describing three years of delayed payment as conduct “in gross violation of the regulatory requirements.” Where a fee direction has not resulted in cancellation, the direction has led to a bar on new business until the dues are paid, as indicated in the orders of Transhermes Aero and Kredx.
Issue 5: The perimeter of the registration
Seven actions concern an entity conducting an activity not covered by the entity’s registration, and the largest penalty was imposed in one of those actions. Ashoka Whiteoak Capital Management, an investment adviser, earned EUR 497,237 in fees under a “fund raising support services” agreement, which the QJAE held to be distribution activity requiring a separate registration; Ashoka Whiteoak also invested in a fund whose manager the entity advised, and provided NAV and reconciliation services for over two and a half years without an ancillary-services registration. The entity’s submissions that the services were incidental to advice, and that the termination of the agreements had rendered the allegations infructuous, were both rejected. Similarly, We Founder Circle’s “Syndicate” memoranda of understanding, under which affiliated entities engaged with prospective investors and earned a carry fee in excess of 3%, were held to be distribution arrangements requiring the distributor-capability assessment mandated by the circular of December 21, 2022, regardless of how the documents were described.
The enforcement actions also settle two further perimeter questions. First, global-access broking (the routing of trades to foreign markets through a foreign broker) requires a prior no-objection certificate from the IFSC exchange under the circular of November 25, 2021; Bonanza Portfolio traded for approximately two years without such a certificate and was penalized, and Evermore Global was found to be in breach notwithstanding the proprietary nature of the trades. Second, a broker-dealer may not conduct an unrelated business under a broker-dealer certificate. String AI’s IT-services revenue, which was the entity’s only revenue, placed String AI in breach of Rule 8(3)(f) of the Securities Contracts (Regulation) Rules, 1957, and the QJAE held that the letter of approval on which the entity relied “is an approval of carrying a business in GIFT SEZ granted by office of Development Commissioner, GIFT SEZ and is not an approval granted by IFSCA” and “does not allow the Noticee to circumvent” that Rule. A special economic zone permission and an IFSCA permission are therefore different instruments, and only the latter defines the activities a regulated entity may undertake.
Issue 6: Investor-facing conduct
The most recent orders suggest that IFSCA’s focus is shifting from presence to conduct. Abans was penalized for seven quarters of missed portfolio disclosures to investors, for failing to undertake half-yearly NAV computations, for commencing investment before the sponsor-contribution waiver had been approved, and for a 14-month vacancy in the role of compliance officer; the QJAE rejected the characterization of these lapses as technical or venial, precisely because the lapses were investor-facing. We Founder Circle was found to have onboarded new investors for nearly two years while the entity’s net worth was below the regulatory minimum, and to have declared a first close at USD 1 million against a minimum corpus of USD 5 million. Rising Omega had documented what was, in substance, an advisory relationship as a non-discretionary portfolio management agreement, exposed a client to derivatives that the agreement did not authorize, provided services before any agreement was signed, and had not published a disclosure document; the QJAE held that “the agreement with retrospective effect cannot absolve the violation.” Bonanza was directed to conduct KYC independently rather than rely on the account-opening forms of the Mauritius broker to which Bonanza referred clients. We Founder Circle’s AML lapses, including the absence of an enterprise-wide risk assessment, an outdated beneficial-ownership threshold and self-certified identity documents, were treated as serious in their own right.
Issue 7: Responsiveness
The seventh issue is not a regulatory requirement but has nonetheless proved decisive. Seven actions record either an advisory that went unanswered or a notice to which no reply was filed. Non-response turned the Darwin and Karvy matters into ex parte cancellations, led to directions against Jashvik even after the substantive charge had failed, and is the first matter recited in each of the aircraft-lessor orders (Contrails Aviation, Nutana Aviation Capital and Transhermes), where the pattern was the same: two advisories, no reply, then a notice.
The Escalation Sequence
Read together, the enforcement orders disclose a consistent sequence that IFSCA has followed before issuing a show cause notice. For ease of reference, the sequence is set out below, with the distance between the first step and the last measured in years rather than months.
| Sr. No. | Step | What Occurs | Illustration from the Enforcement Orders |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Supervisory visit or inspection | Unannounced visit by IFSCA officers; onsite inspection by IFSCA or the exchange; review of filings | Eight visits to fund managers, July 2024 to May 2025; India INX inspection of Bonanza for FY 2023-24 |
| 2. | Advisory letter | Written advisory identifying the lapse and setting a deadline, typically four weeks | Fund-manager advisories of September 12, 2024; aircraft-lessor advisories of December 9 and 11, 2024 |
| 3. | Extension | One-time extension on request, with a firm deadline and a stated consequence | Mplier and Terazo: extension to January 15, 2025, failing which onboarding of new investors would be barred |
| 4. | Interim restriction | Restriction imposed by letter, without a formal order | Mplier and Terazo barred from onboarding new investors from February 2025 |
| 5. | Warning through the exchange | IFSCA directs the IFSC exchange to issue a warning letter to its member | Letters of February 7, 2025 to NSE IFSC and India INX regarding the dormant brokers |
| 6. | Show cause notice | Formal notice under the parent statute and sectoral regulations | 17 notices between December 15, 2025 and January 28, 2026 |
| 7. | Hearing and order | Personal hearing before the QJAE; order an average of 129 days after the notice | 22 orders, January to August 2026 |
The period from the first visit to the final order was 22 months for Mplier, 29 months for Nutana and nine months for Neo. It is pertinent to note that the record does not reward mere engagement with the advisory: Mplier and Terazo replied to their respective advisories, obtained an extension and were penalized, while Contrails and Nutana disregarded the advisories issued to those entities and were not penalized. What the record rewards is cure. Every entity that had fully remedied the default by the date of the order escaped penalty, and the two floor penalties imposed for cured presence defaults went to the entities that had remained non-compliant longest after a deadline requested by those same entities. The advisory purchases time; the value of the advisory lies entirely in what is done with that time. One caveat applies to any comparison across the enforcement orders: the aircraft lessors were charged under the conditions of their certificates and the leasing framework, with no penalty provision invoked, so the outcomes in those cases sit on a different sanction menu from that applicable to the fund managers and cannot be read as lenity.
Defenses: What has and has not Succeeded
For ease of reference, the principal defenses run before the QJAE and the corresponding outcomes are summarized below.
| Argument | Outcome | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Remediation before the notice was issued | No penalty; late fee only | Gateway (reports filed eight months before the notice) |
| Full remediation after the notice, including payment of late fees | No penalty; caution or advisory only | Dynamic Equities; Contrails |
| Corrective action after the notice; lapse repeated over a long period | Liability stands; minimum statutory penalty | Mplier; Terazo (corrective action “does not absolve the Noticee from the repeated failure on its part to comply”) |
| Corrective action after the notice; revenue earned or investors affected | Liability stands; penalty above the floor | Ashoka Whiteoak (“mere adoption of corrective actions does not absolve an entity from legal consequences arising from violations committed by it”); Abans |
| The lapse was technical or venial (the Hindustan Steel line of authority) | Rejected where the obligation was investor-facing or the lapse repeated | Abans; Ashoka Whiteoak |
| An earlier advisory created a legitimate expectation that no proceedings would follow | Rejected | Abans |
| The notice was a composite notice and procedurally improper | Rejected; notice held to comply with the adjudication rules | Abans |
| The entity is inactive, loss-making or pre-revenue | Rejected as an excuse; accepted as mitigation of quantum | Silver Stream; Dynamic; Kredx |
| Absence explained and documented for one officer but not another | Charge sustained in respect of the unexplained officer | Terazo |
| The activity was proprietary; no client money involved | Accepted as mitigation; breach nonetheless recorded | Evermore |
| Change of control and cooperative closure offered after the notice | Did not avert cancellation where the underlying default was grave | LMB |
| No reply and no appearance | Ex parte; cancellation | Darwin; Karvy |
Three propositions emerge. First, timing is determinative: the same lapse cured before the notice has cost a late fee and, when cured after the notice, a penalty. Second, documentation decides the presence cases: an entity that can produce a lease, an appointment letter and a contemporaneous explanation for each absence has been treated very differently from an entity that cannot. Third, the QJAE does not accept that liability ends when the conduct stops; the QJAE fixes quantum by reference to how long the conduct persisted and whether anyone was affected, which is the SEBI Act’s Section 15J grammar applied in a new jurisdiction.
What Follows
Part 3 sets out the sanctions imposed across the 26 actions, from warnings and directions to cancellation, together with the monetary penalties, cancellations and the first protective order freezing investor money. The series closes with the considerations that emerge for an entity regulated in GIFT City and the developments likely to shape the next phase of IFSCA enforcement.
This insight has been authored by Swapneil B. Akut (Partner), Abhishek Singh (Counsel), Anushka Rungta (Associate) and Sankalp A. Dubey (Associate). They can be reached on sakut@snrlaw.in, abhisheksingh@snrlaw.in, arungta@snrlaw.in and sdubey@snrlaw.in, respectively, for any questions. This insight is intended only as a general discussion of issues and is not intended for any solicitation of work. It should not be regarded as legal advice and no legal or business decision should be based on its content.
© 2026 S&R Associates
